1 FRIDAY, JULY 29, 2005
2 CHAIRMAN BARTCH:
Please call the roll.
3 MS. ANGIE FRANKS:
Chairman Bartch.
4 CHAIRMAN BARTCH:
Here.
5
MS. FRANKS: Commissioner Hinrichs.
6 COMMISSIONER SUTTER-HINRICHS: Present.
7 MS. FRANKS:
Commissioner Biele.
8 COMMISSIONER BIELE: Present.
9 MS. FRANKS:
Commissioner Jones.
10
Commissioner Shull.
11 COMMISSIONER SHULL: Present.
12 MR. KEVIN MULLALLY: Mr. Chairman,
13
Commissioners, good morning.
Before we begin the
14
first item of business, I think the staff and the
15
Commission would like to welcome Noel Shull to the
16
Commission. This is his first
meeting.
17 He's an executive vice-president with
18
United Missouri Bank in Kansas
City and from the
19
Liberty area, and should bring a very needed and
20
valued financial perspective to the matters before
21
the Commission.
22 CHAIRMAN BARTCH:
Yes, thank you very
23
much. Thank you for being
here. A banker certainly
24
will be very welcomed with what we're doing, so I
25
thank you, glad to have you, and we'll go about
2
1
business.
2 I would remind everybody that we've got
3
these microphones and you have to get close in order
4
to make them work.
5 MR. MULLALLY:
Mr. Chairman, the first
6
item on the agenda is the consideration of the March
7
30, 2005, minutes under Tab A.
8 COMMISSIONER SUTTER-HINRICHS: I move to
9
approve the March 30 minutes.
10
COMMISSIONER
BIELE: Second.
11 CHAIRMAN BARTCH:
Any further discussion?
12
If not, please call the roll.
13 MS. FRANKS:
Chairman Bartch.
14 CHAIRMAN BARTCH: Approved.
15 MS. FRANKS:
Commissioner Hinrichs.
16 COMMISSIONER SUTTER-HINRICHS: Approved.
17 MS. FRANKS:
Commissioner Biele.
18 COMMISSIONER BIELE: Approved.
19 MS. FRANKS:
Commissioner Shull.
20 COMMISSIONER SHULL: Approved.
21 MS. FRANKS:
By your vote, you've adopted
22
the minutes of the March 30, 2005 meeting.
23
MR. MULLALLY: Mr. Chairman, I might also
24
note that Commissioner Jones' absence today is due
25
to him taking his son to college, so I think we can
3
1
all understand the necessity of
that.
2 The next item on the agenda is the
3
consideration of suitability of licensure of a Class
4
A licensee. This involves the
Penn National
5
acquisition of Argosy Gaming.
The presentation will
6
proceed as follows:
7 First, we will hear from the applicant,
8
Penn National Gaming. Then we
will hear -- included
9
in that presentation, we will hear from the City of
10
Riverside. I believe Mayor Burch
is here. Then we
11
will hear the investigative summary from Sergeant
12
Jeff Smith.
13 We will then have the opportunity for
14
anyone from the public to
offer any testimony with
15
regards to this transaction.
And, finally, we'll
16
have the staff recommendation.
17 So unless you have further questions,
18
I'll ask Jim Deutsch, the attorney representing Penn
19
National to come forward and introduce the
20
applicant.
21 MR. JIM DEUTSCH:
Good morning, Commissioners.
22
My name is Jim Deutsch from Blitz, Bardgett & Deutsch
23
of St. Louis and Jefferson City, and we are here
24
today to present to you the company Penn National
25
Gaming Incorporated.
4
1 I have with
me a long list of dignitaries
2
so I'm not going to try to introduce them all.
3
Instead I would like to just simply thank the
4
Commission for all of the cooperation we've had and
5
all the help that we've had in getting to this
6
point, and to introduce to you the chairman of the
7
board and chief executive officer of Penn National
8
Gaming Inc., Peter Carlino.
9 MR. PETER CARLINO: I take it this is voice
10
activated?
11 CHAIRMAN BARTCH:
Yes, it is.
12 MR. CARLINO:
Good morning, Chairman and
13
members of the Commission and staff.
I am Peter
14
Carlino, Chairman and Chief
Executive Officer of
15
Penn National Gaming. We
brought, I think, half of
16
our corporate staff here this morning and let me
17
walk down the line of dark suits and tell you who
18
these folks are.
19 First in line is Robert Ippolito, our
20
treasurer/secretary of the company.
Bill Clifford,
21
our chief financial officer.
Kevin DeSanctis, our
22
president and chief operating officer.
Jordan
23
Savitch, our general counsel.
Len DeAngelo,
24
executive vice-president of the company. And James
25
Butler from Argosy, who I guess came to keep an eye
5
1
on us, make sure we behave through the presentation.
2 Just a brief history. My staff gave me
3
pages of notes with all kinds of facts and figures
4
and details which I'm sort of disinclined to walk
5
through, so I'll give you the briefest possible
6
summary and then be available for questions, as many
7
as you might like.
8 Penn National started as a family
9
business back in 1972 as a thoroughbred racing
10
company in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and that
11
primary business is still there.
I was president in
12
1972 when it was founded and chairman by 1974, and
13
have been with the company for all of the years in
14
between.
15 We went public in 1994 with Jetset single
16
race track, and from that point, of course, the end
17
process as a public company of acquiring additional
18
racetracks, developing facilities first in
19
Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and West Virginia, and
20
have grown, as you certainly have seen, to become
21
now one of the largest gaming companies in America.
22 Post this Argosy merger, we will be the
23
third largest gaming company in the United States,
24
and I guess that means the world.
We've left some
25
packets of information that have some stories and
6
1
background that I think might be helpful, tells the
2
story even better than I could about who we are, how
3
we've gotten to be where we are today.
But we're
4
grateful to get to this moment.
5 We're particularly excited about the
6
Argosy merger because Argosy brings together two
7
very strong companies. It's a
company that is very,
8
very well-managed, has been from the beginning, has
9
extraordinary properties. But
properties, too, that
10
are quite similar to our own.
We're not in Atlantic
11
City, we're not in Nevada. We
are in middle America
12
and that's the business that we so far have chosen
13
to know and understand.
14 Here in Missouri the Riverside property
15
is spectacular. It's our good
fortune, as I just
16
discussed with Mayor Burch a few moments ago, to
17
inherit some fine work that Argosy has done to
18
take that property to the next level, and as you
19
know, that's still underway, so that's a great bit
20
of news for us.
21 Our operating style, it would matter to
22
you to know that we're largely decentralized. My
23
sense is, and I know that our staff believes that all
24
wisdom does not reside in Pennsylvania.
All markets
25
are local. We have a great
management team there.
7
1
If you look at our history, we make virtually no
2 changes in properties
except maybe changes for the
3
better in capital spent and things of that sort.
4
But our goal is to be a support for the team that is
5
in place so that you'll find no tremors in the force
6
at all as we would arrive here in Missouri. Just
7
try to do it better and the best we can.
8 Now, Kevin went out to meet with
9
the mayor just, I guess, a couple of weeks back and
10
talked about our commitment to the community,
11
something that we take very, very seriously. And I
12
could walk through some of the things that would
13
matter to you in terms of affirmative action,
14 minority hiring,
procurement and so forth, all
15
things that we take very, very seriously as a gaming
16
company.
17 So I think in some ways to make the
18
point that I'd like to leave with you today, that
19
Penn National is completely and utterly focused on
20
being not just one of the bigger but certainly the
21
best gaming company in America.
That is an absolute
22
commitment.
23 So as we would hope to enter your state
24
and to complete this merger with Argosy, I think
25
that's something you can count on.
So any
8
1
questions, I'd be happy to answer.
2 COMMISSIONER SUTTER-HINRICHS: One quick
3
question and this is my band wagon.
I don't see any
4
women and I have not read about any women and I
5
don't see any minorities and that's something I feel
6
very strongly about and I would have liked to have
7
seen women in executive positions and minorities in
8
executive positions in your company.
9 MR. CARLINO:
We don't have many. There
10
are some of the properties -- actually our minority
11
hiring in total is about 55 percent -- or excuse me,
12
about 40 percent company-wide, but at the corporate
13
level, not too many. We have, I
guess, a single
14
female attorney, senior counsel with us, but that's
15
about it.
16 I guess the difficulty is simply finding
17
people that have the experience.
For us, as we've
18
grown rapidly, many of the folks that we've hired
19
come through these acquisitions so that -- we just
20
put our first woman on the board just last year.
21
Again, very tough.
22
I think their
general view is that as we
23
look to fill positions, we look doubly hard to find
24
people to fit those categories.
We generally do.
25
But we haven't made a lot of changes in management.
9
1
As we come to Argosy, for example, you'll see very
2
few changes.
3 It is a commitment that's not enough. I
4
would agree.
5
COMMISSIONER
SUTTER-HINRICHS: Well, I'd
6
like to see you make an effort to do that. I just
7
think it's shameful that there is one female name on
8
here and the excuse is always "they don't have the
9
experience." Well, they
don't have experience
10
because they haven't been given the experience.
11 MR. CARLINO:
Oh, I understand what
12
you're saying.
13 COMMISSIONER SUTTER-HINRICHS:
14
Opportunity is yours, not theirs, to do something
15
about it.
16 MR. CARLINO:
Any other questions? Thank
17
you very much.
18 MR. DEUTSCH:
Commissioners, we do have
19
the mayor here from the City of Riverside. I would
20
like to ask her to come forward and to say a few
21
words to the Commission about what I think is
22
reflected in the letter you have in your materials,
23
but she was kind enough to come here, so Mayor
24
Burch.
25 MAYOR BETTY BURCH: Good morning. Thank you
for
10
1
allowing me to be here with you folks this morning.
2
I'm Betty Burch, and I am the mayor for the City of
3
Riverside. I've got a little
voice problem this
4
morning. It will get
better. Is that better?
5 I've been
with the City of Riverside for
6
thirty years and I'm very proud of this city and I'm
7
very proud of the Argosy Gaming Company. The
8
results of the gaming that has been given to the
9
city has been used for infrastructure in our city.
10
We are building a new city today.
11 It's been ten years and Argosy has been
12
with us that long and now we're going to go with
13
Penn Gaming Company, which I think is going to be a
14
good merge for both of them.
Their hotel is under
15
construction as I speak and I want you to know that
16
the changes in the City of Riverside are almost
17
astronomical. We are building
roads, streets, we've
18
given free trash service, all those things to our
19
residents there just to show the people in the city
20
that we are using our money wisely.
21 So with
that said, I want to tell you
22
that I welcome Penn to the City of Riverside and
23
hopefully we'll have a very good relationship just
24
like the one I've had with the Argosy Casino.
25 Do you have
any questions?
11
1 CHAIRMAN BARTCH:
I don't have any
2
questions, but I take this opportunity to
3
congratulate you because Riverside has done exactly
4
what is an example to the rest of the State of
5
Missouri and industry. You're
doing the exact type
6
of things that you should be doing and we
7
congratulate you for that.
8
MAYOR BURCH: Well, thank you very much.
9 MR. MULLALLY:
Mr. Chairman, while we
10
have the mayor here, I would echo those thoughts.
11
Not only have they done a wonderful job, but I think
12 Riverside is an
excellent example of the use of
13
patience.
14 These things don't happen overnight and
15
a lot of cities get caught up in the trap of wanting
16
to produce instant results and oftentimes throw up
17
symbolic things that are of some value to the
18
community but are more amenities rather than
19
fundamental infrastructure improvements. You know,
20
new community centers with, you know, pools with
21
brass doors and, you know, big statues out front
22
and fountains may look pretty and may make the
23
residents happy, but as far as long-term economic
24
development, I'm not sure how effective those are.
25
Those are the nice amenities that you do after
12
1
you've had some success.
2 Riverside has stuck to the nuts and
3 bolts. They've built
their levee, they built the
4
infrastructure, they put the necessary sewer and
5
water improvements in that can attract large scale
6
industrial businesses to their area, and the last
7 estimate that I
read was they expect over a billion
8
dollars of capital investment in that industrial
9
park over the next decade.
10 That is real economic development and
11
it's taken them ten years to do it and we have
12
probably another ten years to fully realize the
13
potential, but in the end the payoff is going to be
14
very big and it's really a tribute to Mayor Burch
15
and the leaders there to be able to stay the course.
16 The next step of the process would be to
17
hear from the investigative team, which would be led
18
by Sergeant Jeff Smith of the Missouri State Highway