1

 

 

 

           1                  MISSOURI GAMING COMMISSION

                                        MEETING

           2

                                        -  -  -

           3

                                   JANUARY 21, 2004

           4

                                        -  -  -

           5

 

           6                  BE IT REMEMBERED, that the Missouri Gaming

 

           7        Commission held the following meeting at the

 

           8        Riverside City Hall, 2950 Northwest Vivion Road, in

 

           9        Riverside Missouri, on the 21st day of January,

 

          10        2004, commencing at 9:00 a.m. in the morning of that

 

          11        day, said meeting having been called by members of

 

          12        the Missouri Gaming Commission, pursuant to the

 

          13        issuance of due notice to all parties in interest,

 

          14        and the following is a transcript of the records of

 

          15        proceedings had during the course of said meeting.

 

          16                     A P P E A R A N C E S

 

          17                  Mr. Floyd Bartch, Chairman

 

          18                  Ms. Judith Sutter-Hinrichs, Commissioner

 

          19                  Mr. Jack Gant, Commissioner

 

          20                  Mr. George Hartsfield, Commissioner

 

          21                  Ms. Angie Franks, Designated Principal Assistant

 

          22                  Mr. Kevin Mullally, Gaming Commission

 

          23                       Executive Director

 

          24                  Ms. Jennifer Shoemaker, Shorthand Reporter

 

          25                       of Cross Reporting

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

                                                                      2

 

 

 

           1                  MS. ANGIE FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

           2                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Present.

 

           3                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

           4                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Present.

 

           5                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

           6                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Present.

 

           7                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

           8                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Present.

 

           9                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Kevin, first I would like

 

          10        to take this opportunity to welcome the new

 

          11        commissioner to the board.  We are really anxious to

 

          12        have a new commissioner.  We now are four and

 

          13        hopefully shortly we will have a fifth member.  And

 

          14        it is very important to gaming and the State of

 

          15        Missouri that we have a full board to do the

 

          16        business of this industry.  So very happy that he is

 

          17        here.

 

          18                  He spent the -- and comes to us from

 

          19        Jefferson City and the YMCA as executive director

 

          20        there now I believe.  He has spent a lot of time

 

          21        there, spent an awful lot of time with United

 

          22        Telephone over the years and has been the past mayor

 

          23        of Jefferson City.  So that, plus many, many

 

          24        organizations that he belongs to and has been a part

 

          25        of and has been on their boards makes him ultimately

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                      3

 

 

 

           1        qualified to serve with us on this board.  We

 

           2        certainly welcome him and thank you very much for

 

           3        choosing to be on this board, also.

 

           4                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Glad to be here.

 

           5                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Kevin.

 

           6                  MR. KEVIN MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, as you have

 

           7        been notified, this morning one of the more

 

           8        substantial agenda items we had for today has

 

           9        been -- will not take very long now because we have

 

          10        been enjoined, and we will get to that a little

 

          11        later.  So our agenda is markedly shorter than we

 

          12        had anticipated.  However, it creates a -- as every

 

          13        adversity creates an opportunity.

 

          14                  You may have noticed a lot of the

 

          15        tremendous development going on here in Riverside.

 

          16        There is a lot of construction going on.  Anybody

 

          17        who was with us eight, nine years ago when we first

 

          18        came to Riverside to look at this site would not

 

          19        recognize Riverside today.

 

          20                  So I thought it might be helpful for the

 

          21        Commission to get an update on a lot of the economic

 

          22        activity that is going on in Riverside.  And Brent

 

          23        Miles, the Community Development Coordinator for the

 

          24        city, has been kind enough to offer some of his time

 

          25        this morning and bring you up to date on the things

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                      4

 

 

 

           1        going on in this community.  Brent.

 

           2                  MR. BRENT MILES:  Good morning.  I'm Brent Miles

 

           3        and these boards that I packed with me, I pack them

 

           4        everywhere.  I do this presentation a lot.

 

           5                  Like this gentleman said, if you came into

 

           6        Riverside today, any way you came in you saw a city

 

           7        under construction.  If you came in off of Highway 9

 

           8        on to West Platte Road you saw a demolition project

 

           9        happening.  We have purchased four buildings on West

 

          10        Platte, they are demolished, a new roadway will be

 

          11        going through, it will be a four lane, two lanes on

 

          12        each side with a 16-foot center median.  We have a

 

          13        streetscape master plan going on right now for the

 

          14        whole area that will encompass a landscaping,

 

          15        lighting, signage, and then that is what we call the

 

          16        West Platte Road project.

 

          17                  And here is an artist rendering of future

 

          18        development that will occur in that area.  And if

 

          19        you can remember what it looked like just a few

 

          20        weeks ago, this is a momentous drawing of what can

 

          21        occur and what we think will occur.

 

          22                  You can see some of the renderings around

 

          23        the room here today.  Like I said, signage, a

 

          24        16-foot center median, and then hopefully a

 

          25        commercial development taking off on the south side

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                      5

 

 

 

           1        of West Platte.

 

           2                  As you go up to the city north you see --

 

           3        you get into our second section of our road projects

 

           4        which we call middle Gateway Road projects, and this

 

           5        would be starting from where Highway 69 is up until

 

           6        just north of the intersection here at Vivion and

 

           7        West Platte.

 

           8                  You may remember there was a gas station

 

           9        here on the corner, we have demoed that yesterday.

 

          10        We are in the process of designing a new fountain

 

          11        and a little pocket park that will go in there.  And

 

          12        this is a rendering of what that area will look like

 

          13        when we are finished.  This viewpoint is standing

 

          14        where the Corner Cafe is.  I'm sure most of you know

 

          15        where the Corner Cafe is.  This rendering is right

 

          16        there, too.

 

          17                  Then we get into upper Gateway which is

 

          18        our northern boundary which connects into I-29.

 

          19        This, with the middle section of Gateway, will be a

 

          20        three-lane, it will have a center turning lane and

 

          21        the streetscape master plan also is for this area

 

          22        and we are really looking at a nice pallet of

 

          23        landscaping, new lighting, sidewalks on both sides.

 

          24        Something that the people in Riverside can really

 

          25        use.  Most of them walk downtown.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                      6

 

 

 

           1                  We are creating a new master plan right

 

           2        now, it is under way.  We are looking at one

 

           3        possibility of doing some kind of town center

 

           4        overlay district and really make that intersection,

 

           5        that quadrant right there, a focal point of

 

           6        Riverside and really limit the uses and really up

 

           7        the design criteria.

 

           8                  And then this is a rendering of what

 

           9        northern Gateway will look like.  We have one

 

          10        project that is going to be taking off, just did the

 

          11        preliminary site development on it, and it will be

 

          12        one of the focal points of Riverside.

 

          13                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Will you turn that

 

          14        just a little bit more this way?

 

          15                  MR. MILES:  Oh, I'm sorry.

 

          16                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Your audience is

 

          17        actually right here.

 

          18                  MR. MILES:  Okay.  Then as you walked into

 

          19        City Hall you saw a magnificent City Hall and then

 

          20        you also saw our expansion over here.  This is a new

 

          21        public safety facility which will house police and

 

          22        fire.  With our money coming in from Argosy, which

 

          23        we are really thankful for, we have purchased new

 

          24        fire apparatuses and it is funding this.

 

          25                  Then we have a development that is going

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                      7

 

 

 

           1        to be going on to the south of Highway 9 north of

 

           2        635, a new interchange off of -- on 635 will occur

 

           3        and a new road -- four-lane road will connect.  635

 

           4        to 9, I apologize, the rendering is in another

 

           5        meeting right now so.  And that would be a mixed use

 

           6        development, industrial/commercial/retail office.

 

           7        And we are using the funds to, like I said, fund the

 

           8        interchange and fund all the infrastructure for that

 

           9        project.

 

          10                  We have a trail system going on.  It has

 

          11        just been approved by our Board of Aldermen.  It

 

          12        would go on top of the levy system connected to EHM

 

          13        Park, which I don't know if any of you have been to

 

          14        EHM Park. It was funded with Argosy money, as well.

 

          15        It is probably the most underrated park in all of

 

          16        Kansas City in my opinion.  Before I came here I

 

          17        didn't know where it was.  And if you guys get a

 

          18        chance, it is something that you should really check

 

          19        out.  It is a riverfront park right next to Argosy

 

          20        Casino.  And the trail system will have a trail head

 

          21        in there and the trail system will be running into

 

          22        River Park and then eventually be running throughout

 

          23        the city.

 

          24                  Do you have any questions?  I would be

 

          25        happy to answer them.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                      8

 

 

 

           1                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  What was your

 

           2        population ten years ago and what is it now?

 

           3                  MR. MILES:  Our population ten years ago

 

           4        was almost the same as it is today, which is a

 

           5        little over 3,000.  So population hasn't changed,

 

           6        but we have two housing developments that are

 

           7        occurring right now.  One is currently underway, the

 

           8        other one will be starting hopefully this week.  One

 

           9        is 14 houses which is a pretty small subdivision.

 

          10        And the other one is 56, which is a big number for a

 

          11        city this size, especially when you look at our

 

          12        owner/occupy rates.  We have a lot of renters in our

 

          13        city.  And what we are trying to do is to fuel

 

          14        single family development.

 

          15                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  And what is the area

 

          16        of the city?

 

          17                  MR. MILES:  It is 11 square miles, I

 

          18        believe.

 

          19                  MR. MULLALLY:  What are the housing

 

          20        prices?

 

          21                  MR. MILES:  The one with 14, two houses

 

          22        have sold, one was 260 and the other one was 320.

 

          23        Platte County, in a lot of people's opinion, lacks

 

          24        lower income housing, lower income meaning the 180s,

 

          25        which is hard for me to say.  But the subdivision

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                      9

 

 

 

           1        taking off the 56 will be from 180 to about 220,

 

           2        which the developer thinks is a really good niche

 

           3        for anyone wanting to live in Platte County.  And we

 

           4        just approved the plans last night and hopefully it

 

           5        is going to be taking off this week.

 

           6                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Has your municipal

 

           7        court gotten busier as a result of this?

 

           8                  MR. MILES:  I couldn't fully answer that.

 

           9        I don't know what the -- what it was before, so I

 

          10        really couldn't put a number to that.  My city

 

          11        administrator could give you a better answer to

 

          12        that.

 

          13                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  In fact, my first exposure

 

          14        to Riverside was in 1968, the summer, when I first

 

          15        had reason to come over here.  I don't think

 

          16        population-wise it has probably changed all that

 

          17        much in all these years.

 

          18                  MR. MILES:  Uh-huh.

 

          19                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  But certainly it looks like

 

          20        a completely different place from back then and all

 

          21        those projects will actually put you on the map.

 

          22                  MR. MILES:  It will.  And I attribute a

 

          23        lot of that to, I think, in 1982 the city formed a

 

          24        committee called Pride and Progress Committee.  And

 

          25        what that committee did was try to limit the amount

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     10

 

 

 

           1        of liquor licenses in Riverside and maybe some sort

 

           2        of stigma attached to its name, what people viewed

 

           3        Riverside as.  That has evolved in what you see

 

           4        today.

 

           5                  And I think within the next -- I think

 

           6        within the next six months, but I think definitely

 

           7        within the next five years, you will see this

 

           8        transformation.  And a lot of people ask me, you

 

           9        know, "do you really think it is going to look like

 

          10        that?"  And I say, "I sure hope not, I hope it looks

 

          11        a lot better."  So that is my answer.

 

          12                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Well, you have went a long

 

          13        ways down the road, it used to be the reputation was

 

          14        a very rough place to come.

 

          15                  MR. MILES:  That's right.

 

          16                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  And I don't think that is

 

          17        the truth anymore.

 

          18                  MR. MILES:  I don't think so either.  And

 

          19        I attribute, again, to the Pride and Progress

 

          20        Committee.  We have a wonderful Public Safety

 

          21        Committee, which is our public safety force which is

 

          22        police and fire together.  The chief of police

 

          23        does -- he does a very good job.  I think that it

 

          24        even boils down to the point of code enforcement,

 

          25        community caring, community outreach, and the idea

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     11

 

 

 

           1        of fixing broken windows and things like that can

 

           2        really transform a community.

 

           3                  And we are hoping that this

 

           4        redevelopment -- we have increased design standards,

 

           5        we have a grant and loan program that we do, if you

 

           6        come in we do matching funds, $5,000, that we will

 

           7        match it with $5,000 to do landscaping or facade to

 

           8        your building.  And we think that those will be the

 

           9        real catalyst and springboard to an entire

 

          10        redevelopment.

 

          11                  What we have here is two different types

 

          12        of development, which is odd to say. The more

 

          13        redevelopment that will occur in this downtown area,

 

          14        then basically have a greenfield development that

 

          15        will occur out in the bottoms area off 635.  The

 

          16        greenfield development is five minutes from

 

          17        downtown, five minutes from the downtown airport,

 

          18        ten minutes from KCI.

 

          19                  So it is -- when the levy project is

 

          20        complete, hopefully July, probably August, and the

 

          21        interchange comes in, this city will transform.

 

          22                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Did anything get damaged by

 

          23        the tornado that came through this summer?

 

          24                  MR. MILES:  Yes, it did.  We had -- it

 

          25        came up Highway 9, took out roughly four or five

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     12

 

 

 

           1        businesses, damaged some houses across there, then

 

           2        shot right north of City Hall here and took out

 

           3        houses up here to our north off High Drive, and then

 

           4        shot over on its way to Northmoor and took out a

 

           5        multifamily development.  About six of those

 

           6        fourplexes were heavily damaged, all of them had

 

           7        some sort of roof damage.

 

           8                  The insurance has been taken care of with

 

           9        that, we have a developer in here and the progress

 

          10        on that is unbelievable.  I mean, they are making it

 

          11        a lot better than it was before the tornado came,

 

          12        which was the hopes of everyone.

 

          13                  And that is sort of the motto we have

 

          14        in-house is that every day we just try to get better

 

          15        and better and better and eventually we will surpass

 

          16        even these renderings that you see around.

 

          17                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Sounds like your

 

          18        tornado did you a favor.

 

          19                  MR. MILES:  I -- I can't --

 

          20                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  You won't speak to

 

          21        that.  Has -- the population numbers haven't

 

          22        changed, has the composition changed?

 

          23                  MR. MILES:  We have done some initial

 

          24        demographic studies for this master plan.  The

 

          25        things that really stand out when you look at the

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     13

 

 

 

           1        demographics for Riverside is -- especially in

 

           2        comparison to the rest of Platte County is you --

 

           3        the major one is income.  Platte County, I think,

 

           4        averages about 55, median income is about $55,000.

 

           5        Riverside is about 35, which is a sizable

 

           6        difference.

 

           7                  Then also levels of education, and one

 

           8        thing that I think is really going to springboard

 

           9        that number to shoot up is you are in, what I

 

          10        consider, one of the best school districts in all of

 

          11        Kansas City and all of Missouri, the Park Hill

 

          12        School District.  And I can't think of a nicer

 

          13        looking high school that I have seen, especially if

 

          14        you go up to Park Hill South and you look, you have

 

          15        a perfect vantage point of the Kansas City skyline,

 

          16        perfect school.

 

          17                  And then when we get some new housing

 

          18        developments going in, especially in that 180 to 220

 

          19        range and then up from the 220s to the 400 range,

 

          20        obviously the education level, the demographic, will

 

          21        raise.  So I just think it is taking time.  And also

 

          22        with that quality of life increases with new houses,

 

          23        new businesses.

 

          24                  If you come through Riverside you will see

 

          25        a lot of people are walking.  Our demographics show

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     14

 

 

 

           1        that a lot of people don't have computers, they

 

           2        don't have access to the internet.  And we are

 

           3        addressing all those things.

 

           4                  The master plan is what I call issue-

 

           5        oriented.  And we are going to look at possibly ten

 

           6        or a dozen issues that we should be addressing, you

 

           7        know, education level, well, they don't have

 

           8        internet access or they don't have transportation to

 

           9        a place where they can go and work and maybe not

 

          10        stay at home or go and be able to receive a degree

 

          11        at UMKC or Avila or William Jewell or something like

 

          12        that.

 

          13                  I think that they all integrate into one

 

          14        thing and all these issues are part of a big puzzle,

 

          15        so those are being addressed.  And you know, we have

 

          16        to admit that Argosy's revenue stream really helps

 

          17        us implement those things and that is what we looked

 

          18        at, the master plan is.  We looked at a lot of

 

          19        master plans and they gave document upon document of

 

          20        what needed to be done and what we should do or

 

          21        where the problems were, but then they give about

 

          22        two paragraphs on how to implement that.  We looked

 

          23        at it from the point as how are we going to

 

          24        implement that as our main focus point.  And how can

 

          25        we use this capital money to do that and what is

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     15

 

 

 

           1        best for the citizens.

 

           2                  If you talk to or you come to a board

 

           3        meeting, I have been associated with a few different

 

           4        cities, you have to admit that you can see personal

 

           5        agendas and I have to say with this board you don't

 

           6        see that, they always say, "Is this what is best for

 

           7        the city, is this what is best for the citizens?"

 

           8        It is kind of a relief to see that because of the

 

           9        amount of progress that we have had and the amount

 

          10        of progress that is to come.

 

          11                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Is any of the building that

 

          12        is occurring east and south of Brissway in your

 

          13        city, does that stretch that far down?

 

          14                  MR. MILES:  No, it does not.  East and

 

          15        south of Brissway like off of 64th Street, 45

 

          16        Highway?

 

          17                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Right.

 

          18                  MR. MILES:  No, that is in Kansas City,

 

          19        but by the same token I look at a large -- what we

 

          20        did was a five-mile radius and a ten-mile radius and

 

          21        look at the developments and the housing stock and

 

          22        the demographic numbers of those areas.  And we are

 

          23        surrounded by -- we are lucky, we are surrounded by

 

          24        really nice housing stock.  We have Briar Cliff West

 

          25        in Kansas City to our east and then to our west we

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     16

 

 

 

           1        have what is called Riss Lake National, really nice

 

           2        housing stock and houses that range from $400,000 or

 

           3        $500,000 up into the $5 million and $6 million

 

           4        houses.

 

           5                  I don't know if we will ever see a housing

 

           6        stock like that here, but with this development that

 

           7        will occur off of 635 we will capture a huge revenue

 

           8        stream off of those housing stocks.

 

           9                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Thank you very much.

 

          10                  MR. MILES:  Okay.  Thank you.

 

          11                  MR. MULLALLY:  Thank you, Brent.

 

          12        Mr. Chairman, the first item on the permanent agenda

 

          13        is consideration of the November 21, 2003 minutes.

 

          14                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  I move to approve

 

          15        those minutes.

 

          16                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Second.

 

          17                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any discussion?  Please

 

          18        call the roll.

 

          19                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

          20                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

          21                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          22                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          23                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          24                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Approve.

 

          25                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     17

 

 

 

           1                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

           2                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

           3        the minutes of the November 21, 2003 meeting.

 

           4                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, under Tab B

 

           5        through G you have a list of certain suppliers that

 

           6        are up for consideration for re-licensure and

 

           7        Lieutenant Keith Johnson is here to make a

 

           8        presentation.

 

           9                  LT. KEITH JOHNSON:  Good morning, Mr. Chairman,

 

          10        Commissioners.  Background investigations, to

 

          11        include criminal history checks and tax reviews, of

 

          12        the following suppliers and their respective key

 

          13        persons have been conducted in conjunction with

 

          14        their re-licensing.  As a result of the

 

          15        investigations, the following suppliers have been

 

          16        found suitable for re-licensing by the Commission:

 

          17        Osborne Coinage Company; United States Playing Card

 

          18        Company; Acres Gaming, Incorporated; George C.

 

          19        Matteson Company, Incorporated, doing business as

 

          20        GEMACO; Atronic Casino Technology, L.L.C.; Mikohn

 

          21        Gaming Corporation.  Thank you.

 

          22                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Do we do one motion on all

 

          23        of them?

 

          24                  MR. MULLALLY:  If you do it unanimously,

 

          25        yes.  If there is no objection to doing it that way.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     18

 

 

 

           1                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Do we have a motion?

 

           2                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  So moved.

 

           3                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Second.

 

           4                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any discussion or

 

           5        objections?

 

           6                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  No.

 

           7                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Please call the roll.

 

           8                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

           9                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

          10                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          11                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          12                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          13                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Approve.

 

          14                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

          15                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

          16                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

          17        Resolutions 04-001 through 04-006.

 

          18                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, under Tab H

 

          19        is the appeals for the Consideration of the

 

          20        Licensure of Level I and Key Applicants, and

 

          21        Lieutenant Johnson is here for that presentation.

 

          22                  LT. JOHNSON:  The background teams

 

          23        conducted investigations of the following Level I

 

          24        applicants that included, but were not limited to,

 

          25        criminal, financial, and general character inquiries.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     19

 

 

 

           1        The following individuals have been investigated and

 

           2        found to be suitable for licensing by the

 

           3        Commission: Michelle A. Shriver, Vice President and

 

           4        Assistant General Manager at Ameristar Casino Kansas

 

           5        City, Incorporated and Jeffrey M. Jackson, Director

 

           6        of Internal Audit at Ameristar Casinos,

 

           7        Incorporated.  Thank you.

 

           8                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Motion for approval?

 

           9                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  I will move that

 

          10        we approve Commission Resolution No. 04-007.

 

          11                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Second.

 

          12                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any discussion?  Call the

 

          13        roll.

 

          14                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

          15                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

          16                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          17                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          18                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          19                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Approve.

 

          20                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

          21                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

          22                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

          23        Resolution No. 04-007.

 

          24                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, the next

 

          25        agenda item we had intended to present to you, the

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     20

 

 

 

           1        results of an investigation into Sierra Design

 

           2        Group, which prompted the staff to recommend a

 

           3        revocation of their temporary supplier's license.

 

           4                  However, yesterday at approximately 4:30,

 

           5        Mike Bradley was summoned to the Cole County Circuit

 

           6        Court in front of Judge Callahan.  Sierra Design

 

           7        Group sought a temporary injunction enjoining the

 

           8        Gaming Commission and myself from taking any action

 

           9        against -- to revoke Sierra Design Group's temporary

 

          10        supplier's license.  At approximately 5:00

 

          11        Judge Callahan issued that temporary order.  It is

 

          12        my understanding that Assistant Attorney General

 

          13        Bradley will convene before Judge Callahan next

 

          14        Friday.

 

          15                  MR. MIKE BRADLEY:  A week from Friday.

 

          16                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  A week from Friday

 

          17        to discuss that further extension of that order.

 

          18                  MR. BRADLEY:  Right.

 

          19                  MR. MULLALLY:  Or a rescission of that

 

          20        order that would allow us to proceed.  So we are not

 

          21        able to present that to you today.

 

          22                  The next item on the agenda is under Tab

 

          23        J, Consideration of Disciplinary Action, and legal

 

          24        counsel, Keith Essmyer, will make a presentation.

 

          25                  MR. KEITH ESSMYER:  Mr. Chairman, Commissioners,

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     21

 

 

 

           1        you have before you a proposed preliminary order for

 

           2        disciplinary action against Brian Johnson, a Level I

 

           3        licensee.  On October 14, 2003, Mr. Johnson was

 

           4        informed of a possible loss limit violation having

 

           5        occurred at the River King Casino.  Mr. Johnson

 

           6        failed to report this possible loss limit violation

 

           7        to the Commission as required by Title 11, Division

 

           8        45, Chapter 10 of the Code of State Regulations.

 

           9        And this violation remained unreported until it was

 

          10        brought to the Commission's attention by the River

 

          11        King's compliance director, Matthew Block, on

 

          12        October 21, 2003.

 

          13                  For his failure to report this possible

 

          14        loss limit violation to the Commission, staff

 

          15        recommends that Mr. Johnson's license be suspended

 

          16        for a period of 16 hours.  Also, I need to draw the

 

          17        Commission's attention to Paragraph 12 of the

 

          18        proposed order which contains a typo listing Mr.

 

          19        Johnson as a Level II licensee, and ask that this

 

          20        order is approved by the Commission and be approved

 

          21        under the amended form so that it is listed as a

 

          22        Level I, Mr. Johnson is listed as a Level I

 

          23        licensee.

 

          24                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  I move that we

 

          25        approve Disciplinary Order DC-04-010.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     22

 

 

 

           1                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Second.

 

           2                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  I have a question

 

           3        first, though.  I mean, is this 16 hours going to

 

           4        take effect immediately, is that --

 

           5                  MR. ESSMYER:  Under our rules it will --

 

           6        he will have up to 30 days to appeal it.  He has 30

 

           7        days to appeal, it is final in 30 days unless it is

 

           8        appealed.

 

           9                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Is 16 hours a

 

          10        normal --

 

          11                  MR. ESSMYER:  It is the normal penalty for

 

          12        a person of supervisory position such as

 

          13        Mr. Johnson.

 

          14                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  So it is basically

 

          15        two days?

 

          16                  MR. ESSMYER:  Yes, ma'am.

 

          17                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  That is all I have.

 

          18                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Did I hear a second?

 

          19                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Yes.

 

          20                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Call the roll, please.

 

          21                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

          22                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

          23                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          24                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          25                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     23

 

 

 

           1                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

           2                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

           3                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

           4                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

           5        Disciplinary Complaint DC-04-010 as amended.

 

           6                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, there are

 

           7        three remaining proposed disciplinary actions

 

           8        against companies and General Counsel Mike

 

           9        Bushmann will make those presentations.

 

          10                  MR. MIKE BUSHMANN:  Good morning, Mr. Chairman

 

          11        and Commissioners.  Welcome, Mr. Hartsfield.  I

 

          12        would also like to welcome officially Keith Essmyer,

 

          13        who you just heard from.  He is our new legal

 

          14        counsel.  He has been with us just a couple of

 

          15        months, and he has already made major contributions

 

          16        to the staff.  I just wanted to acknowledge that.

 

          17                  And I do have three preliminary orders

 

          18        against casinos for you.  And as was alluded to, if

 

          19        you approve a preliminary order the company has the

 

          20        right to request a hearing in front of a hearing

 

          21        officer and that order only becomes final if they

 

          22        fail to request a hearing or if you approve

 

          23        the recommendations of the hearing

 

          24        officer.

 

          25                  Case No. 04-024 is against President

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     24

 

 

 

           1        Riverboat Casino-Missouri, Inc. and involves playing

 

           2        cards that were used in the company's poker room.

 

           3        The Commission staff received a complaint from one

 

           4        of the company's patrons, stating that on October

 

           5        29, 2003 the patron was playing poker in the poker

 

           6        room when he noticed that the cards in use were in

 

           7        poor condition.  He pointed this out to the dealer

 

           8        and requested new cards, but the poker room

 

           9        supervisor refused to replace them.

 

          10                  On November 10, 2003, when the Commission

 

          11        agents inspected the poker room cards in response to

 

          12        the complaint, they found the cards in use at the

 

          13        poker tables were in poor condition, having smudges,

 

          14        bends and crimps on their surface.  The agents

 

          15        required the company to immediately replace those

 

          16        cards with new ones.

 

          17                  Commission rules contain detailed and

 

          18        specific procedures on inspection of playing cards

 

          19        and removal of any damaged cards.  These procedures

 

          20        are in place to prevent any person from marking

 

          21        cards to increase their odds of winning a table

 

          22        game.  The company's employees failed to follow

 

          23        those inspection and removal procedures, which could

 

          24        affect the integrity and fairness of the game.  In

 

          25        fact, the poker room supervisor and the table games

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     25

 

 

 

           1        manager stated to agents that they were not familiar

 

           2        with the card inspection procedures.  For these

 

           3        violations, the staff recommends that

 

           4        President-Riverboat Casino Missouri be fined in the

 

           5        amount of $25,000.

 

           6                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  I have a question.

 

           7        Suppose it -- what do they do on all the decks of

 

           8        cards, say that you see smudges and say I ask for

 

           9        new cards, do they replace all of the decks then or

 

          10        just --

 

          11                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I believe they replace the

 

          12        damaged cards.  They are required to also, once they

 

          13        replace them, to examine them and make sure that

 

          14        they match the cards that are already in use.

 

          15                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Okay.  I move that the

 

          16        DC-04-024 is approved by the Commission.

 

          17                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Second.

 

          18                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any further discussion?

 

          19        And this is pretty much the normal fine for this

 

          20        type of --

 

          21                  MR. BUSHMANN:  There was a prior case, I

 

          22        went back and looked to see if we had any precedent

 

          23        for this finding.  There was a prior case in

 

          24        December of 2001 where a company was fined $25,000

 

          25        for conducting a table game that had a deck of 54

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     26

 

 

 

           1        cards instead of 52.  So in that case they had

 

           2        failed to inspect and they had let the defective

 

           3        deck go into the game.  So it was the same fine.

 

           4                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Further discussion?  Call

 

           5        roll.

 

           6                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

           7                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

           8                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

           9                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          10                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          11                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Approve.

 

          12                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

          13                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

          14                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

          15        Disciplinary Complaint DC-04-024.

 

          16                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Case No. 04-025 is also

 

          17        against President-Riverboat Casino.  This case

 

          18        involves failure to follow Commission requirements

 

          19        on the storage of slot machines.  On May 14, 2003,

 

          20        Steve Johnson, the Commission's Chief Deputy

 

          21        Director of Enforcement, sent a letter to the

 

          22        general managers of all Missouri casinos setting

 

          23        forth requirements for storage of slot machines.

 

          24        The letter allowed for temporary storage of the

 

          25        machines, but required that slot machines in

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     27

 

 

 

           1        temporary storage be monitored by surveillance

 

           2        cameras.

 

           3                  On October 22, 2003, Trooper Flannery,

 

           4        a Commission agent, observed ten slot machines being

 

           5        stored in front of the stage in the company's

 

           6        theater.  And there were no surveillance cameras

 

           7        monitoring the theater, which violated the order

 

           8        that was contained in Mr. Johnson's letter.  And for

 

           9        this violation, the staff recommends that

 

          10        President-Riverboat Casino be fined in the amount of

 

          11        $5,000.

 

          12                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Has that been

 

          13        rectified since, have they been removed --

 

          14                  MR. BUSHMANN:  They were removed.

 

          15                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Has this happened

 

          16        before or this is a lower fine for this one?

 

          17                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I could find no precedent

 

          18        for this -- that situation so I don't have any prior

 

          19        fines to present to you.

 

          20                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  How long had they been

 

          21        there?

 

          22                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I don't believe that was

 

          23        determined.

 

          24                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Mr. Chairman, I move

 

          25        that the DC-04-025 be approved and adopted by the

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     28

 

 

 

           1        Commission.

 

           2                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Second.

 

           3                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any further discussion?

 

           4        Please call roll.

 

           5                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

           6                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Favor.

 

           7                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

           8                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Favor.

 

           9                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          10                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  In favor.

 

          11                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

          12                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  In favor.

 

          13                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

          14        Disciplinary Complaint DC-04-025.

 

          15                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Case No. 04-026 is against

 

          16        Aztar Missouri Riverboat Gaming Company which does

 

          17        business as Casino Aztar.  The facts in this case

 

          18        are that on October of 2001, the Commission created

 

          19        a new internet website designed to keep casinos

 

          20        informed of changes in approved software and

 

          21        hardware for slot machines.  The Commission staff

 

          22        notified all Missouri casinos several times that

 

          23        they were expected to access the website regularly,

 

          24        download the revoked report, and compare that to

 

          25        their slot data file to ensure that no revoked

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     29

 

 

 

           1        software was used on the gaming floor.

 

           2                  The Commission uses an independent

 

           3        electronics testing laboratory, GLI, to certify slot

 

           4        machines for proper functioning.  On January 29,

 

           5        2002, GLI notified the Commission that it was

 

           6        revoking the certification from some software that

 

           7        was used in slot machines Aztar had purchased from

 

           8        International Game Technology.  The revocation

 

           9        required that Aztar replace the revoked chips within

 

          10        45 business days.

 

          11                  The Commission and GLI revoked the

 

          12        certification for these chips because testing

 

          13        indicated that in certain circumstances a

 

          14        non-clearable error could occur, resulting in a RAM

 

          15        clear which clears all the accounting and play

 

          16        history.  That error would cause a new game to

 

          17        begin, which would change the game's payout

 

          18        probabilities.

 

          19                  The Commission posted the revoked

 

          20        certification of the software on its website on

 

          21        February 4, 2002, notifying Aztar of the revocation.

 

          22        International Game Technology also notified Aztar on

 

          23        February 4th that the revoked chips had to be

 

          24        removed and offered to provide alternate software.

 

          25                  On October 15, 2003, Commission agents

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     30

 

 

 

           1        inspected slot machines located in the company's

 

           2        casino, and they discovered that at least six slot

 

           3        machines in operation in the casino contained those

 

           4        revoked chips.  Aztar removed the revoked chips from

 

           5        operation that day.

 

           6                  Aztar violated Commission regulations by

 

           7        failing to remove and replace the revoked chips from

 

           8        slot machines in operation in its casino within the

 

           9        45 business days after certification of the software

 

          10        had been revoked.  For this violation the staff

 

          11        recommends that a fine be imposed on Aztar Riverboat

 

          12        Gaming Company in the amount of $10,000.

 

          13                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  I had a question.

 

          14                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Yes?

 

          15                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  How many days did it

 

          16        take for them to --

 

          17                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I think it was like 19

 

          18        months, so it was quite a while.

 

          19                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  That is what I heard,

 

          20        it was about 20 months, looked like, but was there

 

          21        any excuse, reason or alibi given for waiting that

 

          22        long?

 

          23                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I believe it was just an

 

          24        oversight by their slot department.

 

          25                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Well, these are -- did

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     31

 

 

 

           1        we follow up on it on a certain case?  Why did 20

 

           2        months go by before somebody told them different?

 

           3                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Well, we have agents that

 

           4        go out and inspect the slot machines, but we have

 

           5        two persons that are specialized in that area in the

 

           6        enforcement section to cover the number of

 

           7        chips, which run into the hundreds of chips that get

 

           8        revoked and replaced, it is hard for them to be able

 

           9        to keep track of them, they do try and find those.

 

          10        In this case there were only six of them in the

 

          11        casino that contained those revoked chips.

 

          12                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  On the oversight did

 

          13        they blame the secretary?  That's usually what

 

          14        happens.

 

          15                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I don't know what their

 

          16        excuse was, sir.

 

          17                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Have we had this occur

 

          18        in the past?

 

          19                  MR. BUSHMANN:  We have actually had this

 

          20        -- yes, a number of times.  The range of fines has

 

          21        been anywhere from $10,000 to $25,000.  In this case

 

          22        there were six machines, which is a relevantly low

 

          23        number.  In other cases there have been quite a few

 

          24        more which generated the $25,000 fines.  And because

 

          25        of the small number of machines involved that is why

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     32

 

 

 

           1        we are recommending the lower range of the fines.

 

           2                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Do you take into

 

           3        consideration the length of time that elapsed as to

 

           4        what the numbers are?

 

           5                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Yes.  And I think that part

 

           6        of the reason of the length of time involved was

 

           7        that came in at the very beginning of this process,

 

           8        when the website was just being developed, and there

 

           9        was a learning curve involved and that may have

 

          10        contributed to why they missed it.  The casinos had

 

          11        to get used to using the website and how to use it.

 

          12        And since this was at the very beginning of the

 

          13        process that could have contributed to why they

 

          14        missed it.

 

          15                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Do I have a motion?

 

          16                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Mr. Chairman, I

 

          17        move for adoption of Resolution DC-04-026.

 

          18                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Second.

 

          19                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any other discussion?

 

          20        Please call the roll.

 

          21                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

          22                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  In favor.

 

          23                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          24                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Favor.

 

          25                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     33

 

 

 

           1                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Favor.

 

           2                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

           3                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  In favor.

 

           4                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

           5        Disciplinary Complaint DC-04-026.

 

           6                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, under Tab N

 

           7        are a couple of proposed rules.  The first of which

 

           8        is something that we have -- Commission previously

 

           9        discussed, granting the chairman the authority to

 

          10        take certain actions for a temporary period of time,

 

          11        thus avoiding the necessity we sometimes have of

 

          12        having these emergency telephone meetings to take

 

          13        care of relatively mundane matters that could

 

          14        be handled by the chairman.  Mike Bushmann is here

 

          15        to explain the staff's proposal to the Commission's

 

          16        request for that type of a mechanism and then you

 

          17        are certainly free to debate it amongst yourselves

 

          18        and decide what you want, but perhaps it is

 

          19        something that we hope articulates what you would

 

          20        like.

 

          21                  MR. BUSHMANN:  This amendment to Rule

 

          22        1.020 provides a mechanism for the Commission to

 

          23        delegate limited authority to the Chairman to extend

 

          24        existing licenses for up to 90 days, in cases where

 

          25        a company's license comes up for renewal and the

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     34

 

 

 

           1        schedule doesn't permit a regular Commission meeting

 

           2        prior to that deadline.  Any extension issued by the

 

           3        Chairman would have to be ratified by the full

 

           4        Commission within 90 days, and the delegation of

 

           5        authority would expire after 12 months unless it

 

           6        was rescinded or reviewed by the full Commission.

 

           7                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  I think what they tried to

 

           8        do was, we have discussed this, obviously, several

 

           9        times.  And to bring everything into play just

 

          10        simply giving the Chairman the ability to handle

 

          11        that situation so a meeting doesn't have

 

          12        to be called until the next board meeting.  And to

 

          13        do that in such a way that it has to be revisited at

 

          14        the first of every year, simply for the fact that

 

          15        boards change and people change and, you know, is

 

          16        that what they want to continue to do.  So that is

 

          17        what we have and certainly before we approve any

 

          18        discussion we should have.

 

          19                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  My only concern is

 

          20        why 90 days when we meet basically every 30 to 60

 

          21        days.  I mean, it really doesn't make any

 

          22        difference, I'm just asking why.

 

          23                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I think the arbitrary

 

          24        decision --

 

          25                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  It could be 60.  I don't --

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     35

 

 

 

           1        30 might not quite do it because we might skip a

 

           2        meeting, but 60, I have been here, what, a year and

 

           3        a half, Kevin, and I don't think we have ever gone more

 

           4        than 60 days without a meeting.

 

           5                  MR. MULLALLY:  I don't believe and I have

 

           6        been here for every meeting, and I don't believe the

 

           7        Commission has ever gone more than 60.

 

           8                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  And that is why I

 

           9        think 60 seemed like a reasonable number since we

 

          10        do.

 

          11                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Certainly.

 

          12                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Are you --

 

          13                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  I would propose an

 

          14        amendment that it be 60 days rather than 90.

 

          15                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  I will second.  And I

 

          16        have got a question, too.  Here, I read that -- in

 

          17        here that it be ratified by a certain majority of

 

          18        the Commission at a public meeting, shouldn't that

 

          19        say at the next public meeting instead of at public

 

          20        meeting?

 

          21                  MR. BUSHMANN:  It certainly could say

 

          22        that, that would be your choice.

 

          23                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  See where I'm -- see

 

          24        where I saw --

 

          25                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Yes, sir.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     36

 

 

 

           1                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  If you are making

 

           2        a motion to amend it I second that.

 

           3                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  I so move.

 

           4                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Is there any other

 

           5        discussion?  If not, could we have a motion to put

 

           6        those two amendments in there for approval of the

 

           7        entire 45-1.020.

 

           8                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  I would so move.

 

           9                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  I will second.

 

          10                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  If there is no other

 

          11        discussion would you call roll?

 

          12                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

          13                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

          14                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          15                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          16                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          17                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Approve.

 

          18                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

          19                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

          20                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

          21        proposed amendment 11 CSR 45-1.020 as amended.

 

          22                  MR. BUSHMANN:  On 11 CSR 45-10.030,

 

          23        licensees' duty to report and prevent misconduct,

 

          24        you may remember that some time ago the staff

 

          25        proposed a rule amendment requiring licensees to

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     37

 

 

 

           1        take reasonable actions to safeguard assets and

 

           2        information, as well as to follow the orders of

 

           3        Commission persons -- or excuse me, Commission

 

           4        employees pertaining to gaming.  During the public

 

           5        comment period several industry members expressed a

 

           6        grave concern with this rule, and after further

 

           7        discussion this Commission withdrew the rule in

 

           8        order to rewrite it.  The amendment before you today

 

           9        is the revised version, which has been edited and

 

          10        streamlined to address the industry's concerns.  The

 

          11        provision relating to complying with orders has been

 

          12        removed, and the assets and information provisions

 

          13        were simplified to require licensees to take

 

          14        reasonable actions to safeguard assets and

 

          15        information.  Examples of these kinds of actions

 

          16        would be closing doors, locking compartments and

 

          17        securing keys.  And the staff recommends that this

 

          18        new amendment be approved.

 

          19                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Mr. Chairman, I move

 

          20        that 11 CSR 45-6.030 are withdrawn at this time.

 

          21                  MR. BUSHMANN:  That is the next one, sir.

 

          22        We were on 10.030.

 

          23                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  11 CSR 45-10.030?

 

          24                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Yes, ma'am, that is the

 

          25        one.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     38

 

 

 

           1                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Do we have a second?

 

           2                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  You got me.

 

           3                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Second.

 

           4                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Could you please call the

 

           5        roll.

 

           6                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

           7                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

           8                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

           9                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          10                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          11                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Well, having been

 

          12        corrected, I still approve.

 

          13                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

          14                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

          15                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

          16        proposed amendment 11 CSR 45-10.030.

 

          17                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Now we are on 6.030 and

 

          18        that is firearms on the riverboat.  The House bill

 

          19        known as the concealed weapons bill that passed over

 

          20        the Governor's veto last fall contained a provision

 

          21        that addresses taking firearms into casinos in

 

          22        Missouri.  That provision stated that firearms may

 

          23        not be carried into casinos without the consent of

 

          24        the owner or manager of the casino pursuant to rules

 

          25        promulgated by the Gaming Commission.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     39

 

 

 

           1        Because of this language, on October 28th this

 

           2        Commission adopted a proposed amendment to that rule

 

           3        that described how an owner or manager of a casino

 

           4        can give that consent.

 

           5                  The concealed weapons bill is not now in

 

           6        effect because of an injunction issued by a circuit

 

           7        court in St. Louis.  That case, which is Alvin Brooks

 

           8        versus State of Missouri, et al., was appealed to

 

           9        the Missouri Supreme Court, and is set to be heard

 

          10        by that court tomorrow, January the 22nd.  The

 

          11        court's ruling will come at some point in the future

 

          12        on whether the law will be allowed to go into

 

          13        effect.  In the meantime, however, our proposed rule

 

          14        is ready to be made final.  Since the law underlying

 

          15        this amendment is not in effect, it would be

 

          16        inappropriate to proceed with the rule change.  At

 

          17        the time the amendment was proposed, we were

 

          18        attempting to get a quick start on compliance with

 

          19        the new rule -- excuse me, new law, and didn't know

 

          20        that it would be hung up in court for such a long

 

          21        time.  At this point, the staff recommends that the

 

          22        rule be withdrawn, pending the outcome at the

 

          23        Supreme Court.  And if the law is allowed to go into

 

          24        effect, we will come back to you at that point with

 

          25        this rule amendment.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     40

 

 

 

           1                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Motion?

 

           2                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Move to approve

 

           3        final order of Withdrawal 11 CSR 45-6.030.

 

           4                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Second.

 

           5                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any other discussion?  If

 

           6        not, please call the roll.

 

           7                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

           8                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

           9                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          10                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          11                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          12                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Approve.

 

          13                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

          14                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

          15                  MS. FRANKS:  By your vote you have adopted

 

          16        final order of Withdrawal 11 CSR 45-6.030.

 

          17                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, the final

 

          18        item on the agenda is a report on the Kansas City

 

          19        area gaming market.  And financial analyst Jim

 

          20        Oberkirsch will make a presentation.

 

          21                  MR. JIM OBERKIRSCH:  Good morning, Chairman

 

          22        and Commissioners.  In lieu of a short meeting Kevin

 

          23        said I could have an hour, which is not quite enough

 

          24        time but I will see what I can do.  We thought we

 

          25        would give you the initial numbers coming out of the

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     41

 

 

 

           1        Kansas City market to kind of color your upcoming

 

           2        visit to the Argosy Casino.

 

           3                  As you know, Argosy recently expanded

 

           4        their casino.  They spent about $110 million, which

 

           5        added about 50 percent to the current gaming

 

           6        capacity.  They used to work off of a three level or

 

           7        a three-deck boat, which was one of the last three

 

           8        boats operated in the State of Missouri.  But now

 

           9        they are on one level -- it is really a deck

 

          10        suspended, it is in water, but it is a deck

 

          11        suspended to the floor, to a base.  So it is kind of

 

          12        an unusual architectural design.  They have got

 

          13        about 2,000 slot machines now which is almost double

 

          14        what they used to have and some additional

 

          15        restaurant amenities.

 

          16                  The Kansas City market, as you see on this

 

          17        chart, is doing about $614 million in annual gaming

 

          18        revenue.  And it has been stuck at that level for

 

          19        about six to eight months, and it has been stuck

 

          20        there despite a high promotional -- a high level of

 

          21        promotional activity in the market, and it has been

 

          22        stuck there despite some smaller expansions.  I

 

          23        think Isle of Capri added 400 slot machines not too

 

          24        long ago and Ameristar rolled out some significant

 

          25        restaurant portfolio.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     42

 

 

 

           1                  Nevertheless, we think that the Argosy

 

           2        expansion is going to add about $31 million to the

 

           3        overall market in the next year.  And that is just

 

           4        due to the expansion, not anything else that could

 

           5        happen over the next year.  So that is about a five

 

           6        percent growth.  And since it is -- and since it is

 

           7        new growth, it is new taxes to the state and the

 

           8        local communities to the tune of about $8.4 million.

 

           9        Now, that 5 percent growth rate is a little bit

 

          10        conservative there, I think it could be a little

 

          11        higher than that.

 

          12                  But now I would like to move on to what

 

          13        that is actually doing to Argosy.  Argosy's 2003

 

          14        gaming revenue was $96.4 million.  And they also

 

          15        have been in that range over the last year and

 

          16        actually recently declined due to the construction

 

          17        associated with the expansion.  And they are going

 

          18        to realize the benefit of the overall market world

 

          19        of $31 million.  We also think they are going to

 

          20        realize some additional revenue coming from the

 

          21        competitors in the market to the tune of about

 

          22        $18 million.  So we think over the next year they are

 

          23        going to show a gaming revenue of about $145 million,

 

          24        which is about a 50 percent increase over what they

 

          25        are doing now.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     43

 

 

 

           1                  So they are going to get some significant

 

           2        benefit out of the 100 plus million dollars they are

 

           3        spending.  Prior to the expansion they only had

 

           4        about $90 million, so add $110 million to that, it is

 

           5        a rather significant amount.

 

           6                  You will see on the second chart, kind of

 

           7        shows how the market share is going to adjust due to

 

           8        the expansion.  You really had Ameristar -- prior to

 

           9        the expansion you had Ameristar and Harrah's vying

 

          10        for the top two spots.  Ameristar recently took the

 

          11        lead due to their expansion.  Then you had Isle of

 

          12        Capri and Argosy battling off for the bottom two

 

          13        spots, and their market share was roughly around 15

 

          14        percent.  Now Argosy is going to jump to about 22.5

 

          15        to 25 percent.  Isle of Capri will remain where they

 

          16        are.  So things have come together in general, but

 

          17        you know how -- in the market.  That is about all I

 

          18        have.  I couldn't use the whole hour, but I will

 

          19        take any questions you might have.

 

          20                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  When is their grand

 

          21        opening, the last of this month?  I saw something in

 

          22        the newspaper.

 

          23                  MR. OBERKIRSCH:  Right.  From a marketing

 

          24        prospective they usually like to wait until all the

 

          25        wrinkles are ironed out with regard to an operation

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     44

 

 

 

           1        before they have their grand opening, their

 

           2        advertised grand opening.  You're right, I think it

 

           3        is later this month, but they opened December 10th

 

           4        on their new facility.  I think the boat is still

 

           5        there, you can really see the contrast and what

 

           6        patrons had to deal with prior to the expansion.  It

 

           7        was a three-deck boat, low ceilings, very smoky.

 

           8                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  How much have they talked

 

           9        about or are they concerned with or are they even

 

          10        concerned at all with Wyandotte County and the State

 

          11        of Kansas if they ever get their act together, which

 

          12        they are trying, what effect it is going to have

 

          13        on Argosy, probably more than the other boats?

 

          14                  MR. OBERKIRSCH:  Certainly more with

 

          15        compared to Argosy than the other boats.  We haven't

 

          16        put any hard figures to that.  The proposals coming

 

          17        out of Kansas are too widespread to really try to

 

          18        nail down what could happen.  We would rather wait

 

          19        and see something start to formulate, but then Kevin

 

          20        will certainly want to know what the impact will be

 

          21        to Missouri and we will certainly report to you on

 

          22        that.  Right, Kevin?

 

          23                  MR. MULLALLY:  Yes.

 

          24                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  You know, we read what is

 

          25        said in the paper, Kevin, but what are the chances

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     45

 

 

 

           1        that Wyandotte County and Kansas will actually do

 

           2        something in this area, over by Cabela's or

 

           3        whatever?

 

           4                  MR. MULLALLY:  Yeah, I mean, it is just

 

           5        incredibly hard to judge, I mean, you know, frankly,

 

           6        Rick Alm probably has a better idea than I do about

 

           7        what the percentage chances are.  But it is -- I'm

 

           8        not real in tune with Kansas politics.  They have

 

           9        been talking about it for so long that sometimes you

 

          10        get a little jaded with it.  But at least I think

 

          11        there are some observers that think there is a

 

          12        better chance this year than in the past.  They

 

          13        certainly have the aggressive support of the

 

          14        governor for something.

 

          15                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Well, they see it as a

 

          16        source for their revenue problems.

 

          17                  MR. MULLALLY:  Yeah.

 

          18                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Is one reason why it --

 

          19                  MR. MULLALLY:  Well, in addition to that,

 

          20        I think there is a lot of development out there that

 

          21        has been fairly successful.  And they would like to

 

          22        see the momentum keep going.  And they think that a

 

          23        casino could be a good part of that.  Again, you

 

          24        still have a lot of Kansans with their values who

 

          25        don't see that as something they would like in their

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     46

 

 

 

           1        community, which is what had prevented it in the

 

           2        past.

 

           3                  MR. OBERKIRSCH:  Thank you very much.

 

           4                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mr. Chairman, the only

 

           5        thing I have left is just a couple of

 

           6        acknowledgments.  He is not here today, but I think

 

           7        I would be remiss if I didn't at least mention in

 

           8        the public session.  Larry Buschjost, one of our

 

           9        gaming enforcement managers, is retiring at the end

 

          10        of next month, I believe.  But he was absolutely

 

          11        instrumental in getting the Argosy Casino opened.

 

          12        He spent many, many nights away from home here and

 

          13        working late hours and extra time to make sure that

 

          14        we had proper regulatory oversight and did a lot of

 

          15        the slot -- a lot of gaming device work there.

 

          16                  We had a retirement celebration for him at

 

          17        the office, but I thought I would acknowledge him in

 

          18        front of you as well.

 

          19                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Certainly we congratulate

 

          20        him and I hope his retirement is nice.

 

          21                  MR. MULLALLY:  He has got about eight of

 

          22        them.

 

          23                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  And thank him very much.

 

          24                  MR. MULLALLY:  He has retired from the

 

          25        patrol and a number of institutions along the way.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     47

 

 

 

           1        But I thought I would also acknowledge two new

 

           2        lieutenants that we have with us today, Lieutenant

 

           3        Keith Johnson, you heard from today, he is going to

 

           4        be in charge of the background unit.  We also have

 

           5        Lieutenant Tim McDonald -- raise your hand.  He just

 

           6        joined us several weeks ago and he is going to be in

 

           7        charge of administration as well as other duties as

 

           8        assigned.  So they have quickly adapted to their new

 

           9        environment and are doing well.

 

          10                  We had the first of what is going to be

 

          11        regularly scheduled meetings with the Colonel,

 

          12        Colonel Stottlemyre, at Patrol headquarters.  We

 

          13        are going to meet once a month with Captain

 

          14        Bloomberg and other key Patrol staff.

 

          15        Lieutenant McDonald was there at the last meeting.

 

          16        And so we think those will be very productive and

 

          17        fruitful and help improve the communication between

 

          18        the Commission and further augment what has been an

 

          19        excellent working relationship over the years.

 

          20                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Kevin, I saw in the paper

 

          21        where Senator Bartle introduced legislation to raise

 

          22        the admission or mandatory admission of $5 a person

 

          23        at such, although I don't think it will have a great

 

          24        deal of chance of passing.  Are there any other

 

          25        bills in there that would affect the gaming

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     48

 

 

 

           1        situation in Missouri?

 

           2                  MR. MULLALLY:  Yes, there are several.

 

           3        Harold Bailey will be preparing a legislative

 

           4        tracking report and forwarding it to you.  We are

 

           5        kind of waiting today.  The governor introduces his

 

           6        State of the State address.  There is some

 

           7        speculation that there will be casino taxes and

 

           8        other gaming legislation as a part of that.  So we

 

           9        will be forwarding your report, you know, I don't

 

          10        know how much chance any of those things have of

 

          11        passing, but I'm sure there will be a lot of

 

          12        discussion again this year.

 

          13                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Has it been introduced on

 

          14        the loss limit, this session --

 

          15                  MR. MULLALLY:  I think there is a loss

 

          16        limit bill already introduced.  There are three or

 

          17        four of them Harold says, so it will certainly be a

 

          18        topic of conversation once again.

 

          19                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  It will be because

 

          20        what I heard on the radio this morning, too, was that

 

          21        some of the legislators thought that we are going to

 

          22        have a general tax increase, but they could look

 

          23        toward the gaming industry to increase taxes.  So it

 

          24        is going to be an interesting session, I think.

 

          25                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Kevin, could you bring us

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     49

 

 

 

           1        up to date on Sigma?

 

           2                  MR. MULLALLY:  Mike Bushmann would

 

           3        probably be better to do that.

 

           4                  MR. BUSHMANN:  Mr. Chairman, as you know,

 

           5        Sigma is operating on a temporary license, which

 

           6        this Commission has granted to them.  That license

 

           7        will expire at the end of February or I think the

 

           8        last week.  Kevin directed myself and some of the

 

           9        Highway Patrol investigators to form a working group

 

          10        to determine exactly where Sigma is on their

 

          11        compliance under the settlement agreement, find out

 

          12        exactly what they need to do to finish that.  I know

 

          13        that you are wishing to move that along, get that

 

          14        process over with, so hopefully in the next week or

 

          15        so we will be able to get together and communicate

 

          16        with Sigma and find out where they are as far as

 

          17        their compliance with other jurisdictions.

 

          18                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  You know, the reason I ask

 

          19        is I know the feeling of the Commission was wanting

 

          20        that to be resolved and losing patience with the

 

          21        time with Sigma themselves so.

 

          22                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I received no

 

          23        correspondence from them indicating approval from

 

          24        those other jurisdictions at this point, that

 

          25        doesn't mean that they haven't, they just haven't

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     50

 

 

 

           1        communicated anything to me at this point.

 

           2                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Do they truly realize at

 

           3        this point that they are on limited time?

 

           4                  MR. BUSHMANN:  I'm hoping so.  It has

 

           5        certainly been mentioned many times by yourself and

 

           6        Director Mullally.  So I would hope they know that.

 

           7                  MR. MULLALLY:  We did receive notification

 

           8        from the Illinois Gaming Control Board, they had

 

           9        completed their action against Sigma which included

 

          10        a $5,000 fine.  So we continue to be the

 

          11        jurisdiction that has proposed the harshest penalty

 

          12        against them, at least as far as I'm aware.

 

          13                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Any other items?

 

          14                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  No.

 

          15                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Do I have a motion for

 

          16        adjournment then?

 

          17                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  So moved.

 

          18                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Second.

 

          19                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Call the vote, please.

 

          20                  MS. FRANKS:  Chairman Bartch?

 

          21                  MR. CHAIRMAN:  Approve.

 

          22                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hinrichs?

 

          23                  COMMISSIONER HINRICHS:  Approve.

 

          24                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Gant?

 

          25                  COMMISSIONER GANT:  Approve.

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     51

 

 

 

           1                  MS. FRANKS:  Commissioner Hartsfield?

 

           2                  COMMISSIONER HARTSFIELD:  Approve.

 

           3

 

           4

 

           5

 

           6

 

           7

 

           8

 

           9

 

          10

 

          11

 

          12

 

          13

 

          14

 

          15

 

          16

 

          17

 

          18

 

          19

 

          20

 

          21

 

          22

 

          23

 

          24

 

          25

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883

 

 

                                                                     52

 

 

 

           1

 

           2                     C E R T I F I C A T E

 

           3

 

           4                  I, JENNIFER SHOEMAKER, Court Reporter, do

 

           5        hereby certify that I appeared at the time and

 

           6        place hereinbefore set forth; I took down in

 

           7        shorthand the entire proceedings had at said time

 

           8        and place, and the foregoing fifty-one pages

 

           9        constitute a true, correct and complete transcript

 

          10        of my said shorthand notes.

 

          11

 

          12                  Certified to this __day of ______________,

 

          13        2004.

 

          14

 

          15

 

          16                                 _______________________

 

          17                                       Court Reporter

 

          18

 

          19

 

          20

 

          21

 

          22

 

          23

 

          24

 

          25

 

                   CROSS REPORTING SERVICES, INC. (816)252-8883